A closer look at the federal electronic logging device (ELD) registry reveals a recurring pattern: a disproportionate share of both active and revoked devices trace back to providers managing multiple listings under one roof.
According to an analysis by Commercial Carrier Journal (CCJ), 381 of the 816 devices currently on the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s (FMCSA) registered list—or 46.69%—belong to companies with two or more registered ELDs, spanning just 121 unique businesses.
That concentration is even sharper among devices pulled from the market. So far in 2026, the FMCSA has removed 221 ELDs from its registry, though a handful later regained compliance and were reinstated. Within that broader group of 2026 removals, 88 company names had multiple devices listed, including five providers responsible for 10 or more listings apiece. Specifically, 125 of the ELDs revoked or voluntarily withdrawn this year (56.56%) came from vendors that had at least two devices removed in 2026, while 193 (87.33%) were built or registered by companies that have held multiple listings over the registry's history.
Behind those numbers is an industry practice known as white labeling, in which a single core software platform is repackaged and sold under numerous brand names.
"We’ve identified entire families of ELDs operating on the same underlying code," Joe Ohr, chief operating officer at the National Motor Freight Traffic Association (NMFTA), told CCJ. "When one device is revoked, another can simply take its place. Revoking individual devices isn't enough. We need to address the entire family."
Brandon Wiseman, founder and president of Trucksafe Consulting, noted that white labeling is widespread across the ELD sector, "and it leads to real enforcement challenges."
Inside the U.S. Self-Certification Loophole
Unlike other major freight markets, the United States relies entirely on vendor self-certification. The FMCSA conducts no pre-market hardware testing, independent laboratory evaluations, or upfront document reviews; getting an ELD onto the federal registry requires only a few hours of online data entry.
By comparison, Canada mandates independent third-party certification before a device can be sold. In the European Union, commercial fleets use digital tachographs rather than U.S.-style ELDs, and manufacturers must submit equipment to designated national type-approval authorities and accredited labs for validation.
"Self-certification is a rubber stamp based on a pinky promise. We have over 1,000 ELDs verified while Canada is less than 50," Ohr said. "We have seen missing and blank info on the certification portal. This allows bad actors to certify unlimited ELDs under different names, and if one is shut down, the driver just loads the new Android app."
Because cloned apps frequently connect to the exact same backend server, drivers can migrate from a revoked product to an active one with virtually no disruption. "This also opens the door for cheating," Ohr added. "Everyone has heard of running two logbooks; this is the virtual twin of that."
Momentum is building to close that gap. The American Trucking Associations unveiled a roadmap this week aimed at overhauling ELD vetting through independent third-party certification and "closing the front door on fraudsters seeking to exploit weaknesses in the system".
While Wiseman agreed that moving away from self-certification is long overdue, he urged regulators to seek public input and weigh potential side effects carefully.
"Third-party certification presents its own challenges," Wiseman said, "and Canada has experienced them, including a long and sometimes expensive certification process that leads to fewer available devices and can result in increased costs to consumers. We have to balance those things in developing a plan."
To curb white-label shell games in the meantime, Ohr recommended requiring vendors to disclose during registration whether a device belongs to an existing software family. If an applicant claims its product is standalone, regulators could scrutinize its filings more closely and require the provider to submit its Android Package Kit (APK) for inspection.
"Run a code comparison and identify," Ohr said. "NMFTA spent a few months doing various processes and was able to analyze close to 80%. This information, along with the process, was shared with FMCSA, and we have volunteered to train on this process."
When Multiple Listings Are Legitimate
Even with the compliance risks tied to cloned software, both Ohr and Wiseman stressed that seeing multiple devices under one vendor's name is not automatically a reason to walk away.
"There are some legitimate providers on the list that have multiple devices," Wiseman said.
Established fleet technology companies often maintain separate listings for distinct product lines, legacy hardware, or corporate acquisitions. Trimble, for instance, has eight ELDs on the approved list—six connected to PeopleNet, which Trimble sold to Platform Science last year, and two covering versions 1.0 and 2.0 of its Oil and Gas ELD.
"While there are circumstances where it makes sense," Ohr said of multi-device providers, "it still needs to be researched and buyers need to be informed."
For motor carriers shopping for compliant equipment, Wiseman advised treating the federal registry as a starting point rather than a guarantee—and doing thorough due diligence, from requesting live product demos to checking references with current fleet customers, before signing a contract.